Explore how the Fourteenth Amendment began the process of applying the Bill of Rights to state governments, starting with Gitlow v. New York (1925). Learn how due process and selective incorporation expanded fundamental freedoms beyond federal action, shaping modern constitutional law.

Multiple Choice

Which case began the process of applying the Bill of Rights to the states through the Fourteenth Amendment?

Selective incorporation through the Fourteenth Amendment begins with Gitlow v. New York (1925). In this decision, the Supreme Court held that the First Amendment’s protections of speech and press apply to state governments by way of the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. This established, for the first time, that the Bill of Rights can limit state action, not just federal action. It wasn’t a full overlay of all First Amendment rights onto the states at once, but it set the crucial principle that state laws governing fundamental freedoms could be challenged as violations of due process. Over time, the Court gradually expanded incorporation to cover more rights through subsequent cases. The other cases involve different constitutional topics: Marbury v. Madison established judicial review; Brown v. Board of Education addressed equal protection and school desegregation; Plessy v. Ferguson dealt with segregation under the “separate but equal” doctrine. None of these initiated the process of applying the Bill of Rights to the states.

If you’ve ever wondered how the rights in the Bill of Rights reach beyond the federal government, you’re not alone. For a long time, those freedoms seemed to belong only to people when the federal government acted. State governments could, and did, place limits that the Constitution seemed to overlook. That tension—between national guarantees and state action—is at the heart of a constitutional idea that reshaped American liberty: selective incorporation through the Fourteenth Amendment.

Let’s start with the Fourteenth Amendment itself. Ratified in 1868, not long after the Civil War, it was meant to secure due process and equal protection for all citizens. In plain terms, it was supposed to ensure fair treatment by the government and to protect individuals from discriminatory laws. But for a long stretch, people argued that the Bill of Rights—these first ten amendments—only constrained the federal government. State lawmakers could pass laws that trampled speech, a free press, or other protections, and the courts didn’t always step in.

Enter the pivotal moment: a landmark case that began to blur the old line between federal action and state power. The story isn’t a dramatic, one-off moment so much as a creeping legal evolution, a slow, careful expansion of what “due process” really means in practice. The Supreme Court started by asking a simple, consequential question: When a state tries to regulate a basic liberty, does the Fourteenth Amendment say that the state must honor the same limits the Bill of Rights imposes on the federal government?

Why it matters, in plain language, is this: the Constitution isn’t a static shield that only the national government wields. It’s a living framework that can, over time, bind state laws to the same standards we hold at the national level. That shift matters to real people—students, workers, parents, artists—because it changes what kinds of state actions are permissible when fundamental freedoms are at stake. It means you don’t need a federal bill of rights to feel protected; state action must also respect those core liberties if they fall under the umbrella of due process.

The first domino in this process, often highlighted in textbooks and courtroom histories, is a case that held that the protections of free speech and free press in the First Amendment apply to state governments through the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. In other words, a state couldn’t constitutionally gag or punish speech in the same way simply by hiding behind local statutes. This was a crucial shift: it didn’t blanket every right from the Bill of Rights onto the states all at once, but it established a precedent that state action could be limited by constitutional guarantees that originated in the federal framework.

Think of it as a legal handshake: the Fourteenth Amendment reaches out to the states, and the Bill of Rights slides over, not all at once, but through a careful process that respects the careful, often incremental nature of constitutional change. The Court didn’t declare all First Amendment rights incorporated overnight. Instead, it laid down the principle that fundamental freedoms—those essential to a free society—could be protected from state interference if the state’s action trampled due process or equal protection.

That initial step didn’t eliminate all friction in American constitutional life. It’s not as if a flood of rights suddenly washed over every state policy. Rather, it set the direction for a decades-long journey. Each new case that followed tested which rights were too fundamental to be left to state discretion. Some rights appeared quickly; others took longer to surface in the courtroom and in social practice. The Court’s job, you could say, was to decide which freedoms mattered most when state action directly touched daily life—speech in public spaces, religious practice, privacy in intimate choices, and more.

And this is a good moment to dwell a little on how this plays out in the real world. Consider speech and press, for instance. If a state passed a law that limited what could be printed or broadcast, the question wasn’t just about the content of the message. It was about whether the state's rule interfered with something—freedom of speech—that the people, through their national and local governments, have the right to exercise. The Fourteenth Amendment’s reach, in this view, makes sure that the same spark of liberty isn’t extinguished simply because the clearing there’s a state border.

Of course, the road wasn’t a straight line. The Supreme Court didn’t stop at speech and press. The concept of incorporation—bringing more rights under the umbrella of due process—grew through a series of cases, each filling in a little more of the map. Some rights were incorporated more quickly than others. The method some scholars describe as selective incorporation is really about choosing, case by case, which liberties are so fundamental that they must be protected against state action.

To anchor this with a broader picture, let’s place the other landmark topics you might hear about in context. Marbury v. Madison is the famous one about judicial review—the power of courts to strike down laws that conflict with the Constitution. Brown v. Board of Education, decades later, reframed the equal protection clause to challenge segregation in public schools. Plessy v. Ferguson, earlier still, established the troubling “separate but equal” doctrine that was dismantled by later civil rights decisions. Each of these cases sits at a different point in constitutional history, contributing to how we think about rights and how they’re protected. But none of them started the project of applying the Bill of Rights to the states in the way that the Gitlow moment—if you’ll pardon the shorthand—began the ongoing, evolving process of incorporation.

If you’re curious about the mechanics, here’s a practical way to picture it. The Constitution sets the stage, the Fourteenth Amendment adds a broad, inclusive rule about due process and equal protection, and the Supreme Court, through a sequence of decisions, tests which specific rights travel with state power and which don’t. Some of those rights—speech, assembly, religion, and later privacy—shown up as essential to the democratic experiment, are the ones that resist being confined by state lines. Others are more flexible, depending on balancing tests and evolving social norms.

A quick stroll through the following decades helps illustrate how this theory translates into everyday life. A series of cases examined whether state laws could limit certain personal liberties, regulate intimate decisions, or control the way people gather and express themselves. The process wasn’t about creating a uniform national standard in a single stroke. It was about building a consistent understanding that certain freedoms must be protected against governmental overreach at any level—federal, state, or local.

You’ll sometimes hear the phrase “incorporation through due process.” That’s a mouthful, but the idea is reassuringly straightforward: the due process clause of the Fourteenth Amendment acts as a constitutional gateway, allowing the Court to apply protections from the Bill of Rights to state governments. It’s a legal mechanism that respects both the federal design and the practical realities of governing thousands of distinct communities with different customs, needs, and challenges.

Now, a small detour, because history isn’t only about statutes and opinions. It’s about the people who live under these laws and the pressure points where rights become meaningful in daily life. Think about a student expressing political opinions on campus, or a journalist researching a local government, or a private citizen seeking to worship according to conscience. The argument that state action must honor fundamental freedoms isn’t some abstract legal theory. It’s a pledge that government power should be checked, that liberty shouldn’t be narrowed by where you live, what you look like, or who you worship.

And this is where the conversation naturally circles back to why the incorporation project matters today. The Fourteenth Amendment isn’t a relic; it’s a living constraint on government action. It invites courts to weigh state interests against individual rights with a careful, sometimes nuanced approach. It also invites us to reflect on the balance between public order and private autonomy—between protecting the common good and preserving the space for personal conscience to flourish.

If you’re exploring this topic for the first time, you might notice the pattern: a bold start with a core idea, followed by a gradual, steady expansion as new questions arise. The conversation doesn’t end with a single decision or a neat list of rights transferred from federal to state control. It’s an ongoing dialogue about what it means to be free in a diverse democracy, where power is exercised at multiple levels and where every branch of government has to answer to the people.

In the end, the story of selective incorporation is a story about constraint and protection working together. The Fourteenth Amendment gives the judiciary a tool to ensure that fundamental liberties aren’t left to the mercy of local majorities. The Bill of Rights provides a set of guardrails that guide how government can and cannot act. And the ongoing dialogue—through new cases, new social concerns, and new interpretations—keeps refining how those guardrails function in a changing world.

If you’re looking for a mental image to carry forward, imagine a road map that starts at the national level but has spokes branching out to every state, every city, every town. The Bill of Rights provides the compass needle; the Fourteenth Amendment provides the route for bringing protections along that journey. The result is a constitutional landscape that aims to secure the same essential freedoms for all people, wherever they live, while recognizing the practical realities of governing a vast and varied nation.

So the next time you hear about how rights travel, you’ll know there’s more to it than a single courtroom decision. It’s about a deliberate, patient process that recognizes the core idea: liberty deserves not to be trapped behind borders, but to be safeguarded wherever it matters most—in the everyday lives of Americans. That’s the throughline that began with a pivotal ruling in the 1920s and has continued to shape the fabric of constitutional law ever since. And it’s a reminder that the law, while precise, is also a living conversation about what it means to be free.